rss
20 April 2010 ,

Are soy products my friends?

Photo courtesy of Flickr and unite Photo courtesy of Flickr and unite
Hey folks. It's Tuesday. Let's learn about soy products! When I first became a vegetarian years and years ago, it was easy. I just substituted my meat consumption with soy product consumption. Invited to a bbq? Bring a veggie burger pattie for the grill. Craving street meat? Grab a veggie dog and smother it with spicy mustard and relish. Heading to mom's for Thanksgiving? Ask her to toss in the horrifying product known as the "tofurky" and you'll be fine!

In the last years I've gone back and forth between being a farmers' market fed Toronto vegetarian and sitting in front of a long wooden table in Argentina sampling every single part of the cow (skip the intestines, as they are just plain yuckie), while drinking copious amounts of red wine. These days I'm back to my Toronto farmers' market ways with the understanding that Ontario produces some darn decent wines at good prices.

So what about the soy products (I type this, pause, and take a sip of my soy latte)? Folks, the more I learn about industrial farming and food processing in general, the harder it is to eat food products - that is, if you have a choice (and I know how fortunate I am to have choices). Just the other day, I came across a soy scorecard that lays out which brands and products are, um, poisoning me with HEXANE, and which really do have my health and well-being and that of the larger ecosystem in mind and practice. 

The scorecard and report come from The Cornucopia Institute in the U.S., but scores products in the U.S. and Canada. Below is the happy part of the scorecard - the folks who are getting it right. The criteria is pretty comprehensive, as it looks so far as ownership structure and sourcing and farmer relations. I was excited to see Eden Foods at the top of the list, as I've been known to use their veggie crumble in my gourmet shepherd's pie. Yummy.

scorecard.jpg

My solution to the complexity that is the soy product industry? Make as much of my own food as I can from raw, whole ingredients (sourced locally and organically where possible). And trust me, folks, if you aren't already living this way, I can tell you that it takes a lot of time and dedication, but it's very satisfying and can be a heck of a lot cheaper. However, I encourage you to involve the whole family (especially if you're a woman), as sometimes you start to feel like a 1950's housewife and that throws us back to essential questions about division of labour, compensation, etc. (See this fantastic piece in Grist about "femivores," which wonders if we're radicals or merely frontier throwbacks.) Now I'm off to see what brand of soy milk is in my latte.

, ,
Written by: Melanie Redman

Melanie Redman

Melanie Redman is a Social Mission Collaborator with more than 10 years of direct experience in strategic, leadership and advisory roles across the social mission sector in the U.S. and Canada. She calls many places home - most recently Toronto, Buenos Aires and Seattle - but was sprouted from the Ozark Mountains of Southern Missouri. Learn more about her work at www.melanieredman.com or on LinkedIn.

 

Responses to “Are soy products my friends?”

5
Sarah Selecky Says: April 20, 2010 9:12 AM

Great article - thank you! I love the soy scorecard (interesting that Silk scores so low). (Unfortunately, Natura isn't on the list, which is the one that my favourite cafe uses in my soy lattes.)

We make our soy milk at home, with organic beans and a nifty soy milk maker like these ones: http://www.harvestessentials.com/soymilkmakers.html?gclid=CI7yjJm6laECFRRM5QodC0pFUw. It takes about 30 minutes. I recommend it!

Jenny B Says: April 20, 2010 11:57 AM

Hi Melanie,
I've been trying to limit the soy consumption lately, esp. things like veggie dogs and and sausages and the like (definitely break the 5 ingredient rule). About the whole "femivore" thing -- I've been thinking about this, and here are my thoughts: Any occupation can be a gilded cage, regardless of whether it is paid labor, or unpaid domestic labor. What sets us free from the cage is the *meaning* we find in our work. Everyone, women and men, should be free to do meaningful work. Not everyone will find the same meaning in the same things. I find feeding and caring for my family to be meaningful. Many people find their paid jobs to also be meaningful. I do believe it's unfair that we are not compensated financially for domestic work, but that is where the sexism comes in. The world does not value this work, at least in terms of where it puts its money, and if you don't have money, you don't have power or prestige. But I don't have to live by this (dare I say, male?) paradigm. I can create my own paradigm, or in other words, take back my power.

Nice blog, thanks for putting it out there!

Katie M Says: April 25, 2010 10:45 AM

Thanks Melanie, we've gotten lazy in our soy consumption (we eat enough Yves Veggie to have stock in the company) and this is a good reminder that going veggie doesn't automatically bestow food goodness.

Melanie Redman replied to comment from Katie M Says: April 26, 2010 11:17 AM

Hi Katie. Your comment reminded me of my visit to the Green Living Show this last Friday. I wanted to go through the 400 + exhibits with a great big cane and drag the "greenwashers" off the stage (complete with laugh and applause tracks playing in the back ground). Similarly, just because something is made with soy, or uses the terms "natural" or "organic," in its literature doesn't make it automatically good for us or the environment. This shit is complex and takes a lot of thought and planning. I would love to eat frozen, organic, veggie entrees every night and save myself the work, but that just isn't sustainable for my body or the planet.

Sunka Says: April 27, 2010 2:24 PM

Want another level of complexity? Soy itself is bad for you.
When people eat soy it breaks down straight into estrogen (amongst other things). The more soy you eat, the more estrogen builds up in your system.
With men this causes things like moodiness,depression, weight gain "Bitch tits", erectile dysfunction, all manner of prostate issues and, of course, cancer. Not to mention going a long way to explaining why veggie boys are such Nancys. ;)
With women it causes menstral issues, bone weakening and reproductive cancers (like the one that killed my mom. That's how I found out about this, from her oncologist.)
Given that soy lecithin is one of those things that's in EVERYTHING right up there with High Fructose Corn Syrup and MSG it's little wonder the industrialized societies are in such bad shape.